Rye vs. Bourbon: What’s the Difference?

When it comes to American whiskey, it’s a tale of two spirits: Rye Whiskey and Bourbon. Think of bourbon as the smooth talker—rich, sweet, and full of caramel charm—while rye is the bold, spicy rebel that keeps things exciting. Both have deep roots in America’s whiskey-making tradition, but their personalities (and flavors) are shaped by one key difference: the grain.

Bourbon leans heavily on corn, harvested from sun-drenched fields, giving it that signature sweetness. Rye, on the other hand, is all about that spicy kick, thanks to hardy rye grain—grown in fields that once fueled America’s earliest distillers. From farm to barrel, both whiskeys carry the spirit of authentic, hands-in-the-dirt craftsmanship that makes each sip taste like history in a glass.

WhistlePig PiggyBack 100% Rye: With a mash bill of 100% Rye to capture a 100% bold, spice flavor profile. PiggyBack’s unique strength of precisely 96.56 proof is the optimal match in the strength-sweet-bitter cocktail triangle, making it a bartender’s dream.

WhistlePig PiggyBack 100 proof Bourbon: With a dash of rye on top of a high corn mash bill our Bourbon is aged six long years to add layers of flavors and complexity before bottling. 

But which one is right for you? In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences in ingredients and flavor, plus the best ways to enjoy each—whether neat, on the rocks, or mixed into a classic cocktail. By the end, you’ll know exactly which whiskey suits your style (or if you need both on your shelf!).

‍

Rye & Bourbon Ingredients

Whiskey starts in the fields, and when it comes to rye vs. bourbon, the grain makes all the difference. Bourbon is a corn-lover’s dream, required to be made from at least 51% corn, with the rest usually a mix of rye, barley, or wheat to top off the sweet taste and add subtle accents of flavor. That corn-heavy mash bill is what gives bourbon its signature sweet, smooth, and caramel-rich profile—like a warm hug in a glass. Rye, on the other hand, plays by spicier rules. With a mash bill of at least 51% rye grain, this whiskey delivers a bold, peppery kick that wakes up your taste buds. But let’s not beat around the bush, WhistlePig uses 100% rye grain in our Rye Whiskeys. Think of bourbon as a slow, sweet country ballad, while rye is more like a fast-paced fiddle tune—it’s got energy, spice, and a bit of an edge. Whether you’re craving something mellow or something that keeps you on your toes, the grain in your glass makes all the difference.

‍

Do Rye and Bourbon Taste Differently? 

If bourbon and rye were people at a party, bourbon would be the easygoing charmer, smooth and sweet with a warm vanilla handshake. Rye? That’s the lively one with a bold, peppery personality that keeps the conversation exciting. Bourbon’s high corn content gives it a rich, velvety texture, packed with flavors of caramel, vanilla, and toasted oak—a little like biting into a crème brûlée with a hint of smokiness. Rye, with its spice-forward mash, hits differently: drier, livelier, and full of pepper, baking spice, and citrus zest. Some liken it to biting into a slice of fresh-baked rye bread, while others say it’s like a whiskey with a built-in kick. The WhistlePig PiggyBack 100 Proof Bourbon leans into the sweetness with an exciting flavor profile while our classic WhistlePig PiggyBack 100% Rye brings that signature spice. Whether you’re after something smooth and comforting or bold and fiery, your taste buds are in for a ride.

‍

Is Rye Whiskey or Bourbon Right for Me? 

It all comes down to your vibe. If you love smooth, sweet sips with notes of caramel and vanilla, bourbon’s your best bet. But if you’re all about that bold, spicy kick with a little extra edge, rye is calling your name. The good news? There’s no wrong answer—only more whiskey to explore. So why not try both and let your taste buds decide?